In a recent discussion about the performance of a separate anthem during the NFL championship game, some observers voiced strong opinions against the idea of having a Black national anthem. The crux of the argument is clear: America is a nation built on unity, and that unity is best represented by one anthem — the national anthem. The insistence on maintaining this singular, unifying symbol speaks volumes about the core values of American identity.
Many Americans might say it is inappropriate to introduce a separate anthem, especially at a prominent event like the Super Bowl. When one considers that the event is meant to showcase the unity and celebration of sportsmanship across all demographics, allowing a separate anthem undermines that goal. It raises questions about the implications of division in a setting that is supposed to bring people together. This inclination towards dividing national pride into separate categories does not resonate with the idea of one nation under God.
Critics of the separate Black national anthem argue that such distinctions only serve to highlight differences where there should be commonality. If separate anthems are entertained for one group, there could be demands for similar recognition for various other cultural or ethnic groups. Should the NFL accommodate a Mexican national anthem next? Or perhaps an anthem for every conceivable demographic? The slippery slope here is clear, and it leads away from the foundational principles of American unity.
The spirit of nationalism revolves around shared values and common ground. The national anthem is not just a song; it represents the sacrifices and struggles of all American citizens. It stands for freedom and justice for all, irrespective of race. The idea of having multiple anthems plays into the hands of divisive politics, where identity overcomes the collective identity of being American. In this case, true patriotism is best represented when everyone stands together under the same flag.
Furthermore, the point is raised that if the separate anthem is to be recognized, it should ideally be a space within a cultural or educational context — think about historically Black institutions where such performances may celebrate heritage without compromising the essence of national unity. However, it is critical to remember that patriotism should prevail in national venues, allowing all citizens to rally behind one anthem, fostering a spirit of unity instead of division. In this land of liberty and opportunity, it is high time to prioritize the anthem that represents the collective achievement of all Americans rather than the interests of a few.
